Are we a real asset to Title and lenders?

I recently asked several title companies to raise my fees for loan-signing assignments due to the current economic climate. One replied: “I have not received approval from leadership to increase your fees any higher. Honestly, for the areas you cover, your rates are double to triple our average fees. Maybe we should remove the distant counties from your profile—we do not want you taking a loss on our orders.” The market is oversaturated with both experienced and newly commissioned loan signing agents, all facing higher fuel and supply costs. Unlike real estate agents, loan officers, and loan originators—revenue producers who are compensated accordingly—we are treated as service providers who offer borrowers convenience rather than directly increase a company’s profits. We improve the borrower’s experience and save clients the time and inconvenience of visiting an office, often during work hours. However, the abundance of available LSAs leaves us with few alternatives and little leverage to negotiate the current fee structure. For those with full-time jobs, loan signings may provide supplemental income; for full-time LSAs, low fees can have a significant monetary impact. Those of us with multiple business lines are also entitled to protect the profitability of each one. Today, each mile driven, each page printed, including other operational costs makes a difference to our ability to thrive. Now that I have vented, I pray the best for us all to prosper.

4 Likes

Title companies don’t dictate your fees, Carl. Those notary fees have remained unchanged for decades. The signers see it on their settlement statements, approve it, and the only thing that happens is the spouse sees the fees and decides she might try becoming a loan signer. The new sheriff in town now stands squarely in the middle of a $250-$350 notary fee. It remains to be seen how much more “juice” can be squeezed out of that lemon before the tree dies.

2 Likes

LOL…that’s a good one. That’s sort of the way that I got into this business. I had just retired and was looking for something to keep me busy and also provide some income beyond Social Security. We had a signing agent come to our house to have documents signed for a refinance of our house. By the time the signing was over, I said to my wife “Hey, I can do what she did”. Not long after, I was a commissioned notary and a certified signing agent. The rest, as they say, is history :slight_smile:

4 Likes

Love the humor in your comment.:grin: At least I hope my interpretation of your comment was on point :backhand_index_pointing_right:

2 Likes

Same thing happened to me too. :grin:

At some point you have to ask am I worth triple. Maybe your answer is yes. I think to title companies they have a problem saying yes. The woman who mentored me and convinced me to start as a loan signing agent didn’t renew her commission because she said she could not drop her fees to get work and she wasn’t getting any work charging what she charged.

2 Likes

You’re worth what someone is willing to pay you. That’s the bottom line.

2 Likes

Totally agree with @steves11 statement. Business economics creates a clear dynamic: when loan signing agents are oversupplied in a geographic area, companies can benefit from the intense competition for a limited number of signing orders. It put companies in a strong position to cut the signing fees.

1 Like

Are we assets like plumbers, carpenters, bricklayers, and electricians? Absolutely! The standard rate for a remote closing (loan signing) is $250. I was getting $250 per loan in 2001; think about that. For example, my combined dinner, bar tab, and tip last Friday night was $230, and my wife and I split the main course. We booked our dinner reservation on the OpenTable app. Now, can you imagine if OpenTable took $170 and reimbursed the restaurant $60? OpenTable would be out of business in a week. Did you know hiring services are 100% digital? Just let that sink in. I could run a hiring service from the back of my Tesla. Greed is the only logical reason for this theft of service.

2 Likes