Curious how other LSAs are handling this, because I’ve seen a lot of different approaches and I’m not sure any of them hold up well.
After a signing, I’m sure many of us have the same dilemma. Delete the scan-backs right away and you risk being stuck if the title company says they never got them. Keep them “just in case” and you have borrower NPPI sitting on a laptop or in Google Drive, which doesn’t sit well with GLBA or the data-handling language in a lot of vendor agreements.
The Mobile Notary Zone breach last year, after which New American Funding cut ties with that vendor, made me rethink my own process. So I’m curious:
How long do you keep scan-backs after sending them back, and where do you store them in the meantime?
Has a title company ever asked you to prove you deleted documents, or put data-destruction language in an agreement you signed?
Has anyone ever come back asking for a file you’d already deleted? How did you handle it?
Where do loan docs live between getting the order and the signing? Downloads folder, email, cloud drive, something else?
Full disclosure: I’m a working notary (and former HIPAA Privacy Officer) and I’m building a tool to automate this, so I’m trying to find out whether the problem is as real for you as it is for me. Honest answers help either way, including “this isn’t an issue for me.”
put 'em on a flash drive…delete when paid
And I have another issue that you can add to your ‘list of worries’:
This may not be the latest scam, but it’s an enduring one. Well-funded with excellent programs designed for Scammers TARGET signing services to get into their database of notaries–where just about everything the SS demands is exactly what a scammer needs to know to steal notaries info (SS #, bank info for Direct Deposit, home address, email, cell #, drivers license #, etc.) is right there! And downloaded by Scammer in a New York minute–deleting any trace that an unauthorized person accessed the info.
With new SS popping up daily (often 1-person WFH with little IT knowledge and little money to spend protecting their notaries), we all should be on high alert and think twice before providing OUR NPPI.
@Arichter I completely understand why you hold onto them until the check clears—protecting our paychecks from the “blame game” is so important, and it feels like we are constantly having to cover our own bases!
Your point about scammers targeting Signing Services for our info is exactly what keeps me up at night too. It just proves that we really can’t trust these platforms to hold our data or the borrower’s data securely.
Because of those exact fears, I actually shifted my workflow away from physical drives a while back. I use a strict 7-day grace period instead. After a closing, I give myself exactly 7 days to make sure it funded and my bookkeeping is updated, and then my system automatically executes a cryptographic purge of the files.
It took me a while to build that automated workflow for my own business, but it gives me so much peace of mind knowing there is absolutely zero local residue left anywhere on my end once that 7-day timer hits.
It is wild the lengths we have to go to just to stay compliant and protect ourselves!
It’s a good idea to also keep shipping receipts until the check clears, so if the title company claims that they never got the documents back, you can prove that you dropped them off on time and they’ll have to find someone else to blame.
I have a moble scanner that is bluetoothed to my phone. It scans 100 pages per minute and is set to do continuous scanning until told not to. I also scans ID’s really well. I paid $400 for it, so it better do a good job. I also have it set to detect multiple sizes.