So some states, from what I’ve seen twice now, requires forms done for two different title companies. Seller forms in those transactions are doubled. Should we be compensated for doing double the docs? I realize that it’s not a lot of paperwork, I get it, so please do not use that point. All parties involved are paid, so should we be compensated for each entity we do paperwork for or should it be allowed and accepted without raising questions? Just trying to figure out if more should be given/asked for for these situations.
I’d look at the situation as a ‘how many pages total’ issue.
I personally find it to be counterproductive to make decisions on who gets paid what based on a settlement statement I see where Notaries do that a lot but I just don’t bother. It’s not the number of Title companies. It’s the number of Signers from my way of thinking.
So would you do 2 closings for the price of one? That’s the perspective I’m thinking of. I’m doing paperwork for each title office.
It’s not a lot of pages. Really isn’t but it’s more time and everything. I could have done it in 17 pages, but with the second company, it ended up being 40.
Not sure if I understand OP’s query.
IME, if I’m handling both the seller’s package AND the buyer’s package, yes, there may be 2 separate title companies involved. One for the seller and one for the buyer. A Copilot Search explains this: Why a Real Estate Transaction Might Require Two Title Companies
In many U.S. real estate closings, two separate title companies are used because the transaction involves two distinct title insurance needs — one for the buyer (owner) and one for the lender — and each may be handled by a different firm.
1. Two different types of title insurance
-
Owner’s policy: Protects the buyer if there are title defects, liens, or other issues that affect ownership. This is the policy the buyer’s chosen title company issues
YouTube. -
Lender’s policy: Protects the mortgage lender if the property’s title is challenged, ensuring the lender can recover the loan amount
www.thigpenjenkins.com.
Because these policies serve different parties and have different coverage purposes, many transactions require two separate policies — and often two separate title companies to issue them
YouTube+1.
2. Split closings
Some transactions are structured as “split closings,” where the buyer and seller (or buyer and lender) close at different times or with different title companies
www.highlandtitle.com+1. This can happen when:
-
The buyer and seller each prefer a different title company (often based on past service quality).
-
The lender requires its own title company for the loan policy.
-
The parties want to avoid a single firm acting as fiduciary to both sides, which could create conflicts of interest
www.highlandtitle.com.
3. Lender requirements
If the buyer is not paying cash, the lender will usually require its own title company to issue the lender’s policy. This is a standard industry practice and is not optional in most mortgage transactions
www.thigpenjenkins.com.
4. Coordination and communication
When two title companies are involved, they must coordinate closely to ensure all documents, funds, and title work align. This can add complexity, but it also allows each party to work with a firm they trust and that can advocate for their specific interests
www.highlandtitle.com+1.
In short: A single transaction may require two title companies because the owner’s policy and the lender’s policy are separate legal products, often issued by different firms, and in some cases the closing is split between two companies for convenience, trust, or lender requirements
YouTube+2.
Again IME, if I’m handling 2 files – even at the same time and same location – I charge 2 separate fees (for example: $200 for the seller’s package AND $200 for the purchase package for a total of $400. No, I do not give a discount for one of the files because I’m going to the same location. I did that once, many years ago for 2 property refis signing at same location. Long story short, one of those files cancelled at the last minute – the full-fee file – and I had driven for over an hour for 1 discounted fee plus the print fee for the other file. Lesson learned. Each file/assignment carries its own fee.
Whooo lot in that reply (playful) It was not a buyer/seller like your example. Yes, it’s essentially doing 2 seller closings, one for each party. Was 40 pages total. 17 for one company, 23 for the other. It’s happened to me twice, for some reason in michigan transactions. Again it’s essentially a double seller, same property, you execute docs for each title company on the same property.
Separate note, shoot, where do you live that you get 200 for a seller when you’re 3rd party contracted? All I can manage is 95-100 unless I’m driving over an hour and they only use me in that scenario as a last resort. See lot of low ball offers lately trying to give 50 and I’m like helllllll no lol.
@yolicue
Absolutely
Each file/assignment carries its own Fee.
My direct experience mirrors yours . . . ![]()
Many years ago, 1st time performing dual-title signing (buyer AND seller - NOT disclosed by the Scheduler), cancelled last-minute, extended drive time =>
Singed
on the expenses.
Accurate: Lesson Learned!
![]()
If it were two I’d probably raise the total fee. After pointing out to whoever hired me it’s two transactions. I’ve done that before.
I just want to make sure I painted it clear: 1 property, 2 sets of title docs for the same transaction. Would you still charge more?
If it was one set of signers only - depends on what the fee is in the first place.